billings gazette logo Contact Us | Subscribe Log In | Register
print this storye-mail this story (5) rate

Published on Sunday, November 18, 2007

Gazette Opinion: Meeting Billings' work force challenge
With Montana's unemployment rate sinking below 2 percent - the lowest in the nation - and Yellowstone County's rate as low as 1.5 percent, a work-force shortage is challenging employers throughout the state, and especially in Billings.

The labor crunch has arrived after 15 years of steady economic growth in Montana's largest city. Personal income, per capita income and jobs available have all increased in Yellowstone County.

Economist Larry Swanson of the O'Connor Center for the Rocky Mountain West drew this picture of the local economy in his talk to 300 Billings business people and community leaders at a breakfast forum last week at Montana State University-Billings. Sponsored by Celebrate Billings partners (MSUB, Billings Clinic, St. Vincent Healthcare, the Foundation for Community Vitality and The Billings Gazette), the forum was organized to spur discussion and action on solutions to work-force issues.

Jobs in cities

Likewise, Montana's other biggest cities are engines of economic development. Between 2000 and July of this year, Gallatin County's work force expanded by 10,138 people, Yellowstone County's by 8,399, Flathead's by 6,743 and Missoula's by 6,172. Counties neighboring urban centers also saw strong job growth with Ravalli County expanding its work force by 2,385 during the seven-year period.

People are going where the jobs are being created. Seventy percent of Montana's population lives within 40 miles of its seven largest urban areas.

In the tight labor market, many workers are looking for better jobs. Nancy Boyer, who runs a job counseling business, told the breakfast audience that she's been busy despite the low jobless rate because people are wanting to change jobs. This situation creates opportunities for employers to move workers into more productive jobs.

At a small group discussion after the breakfast forum, most participants chose "work force shortage" as their discussion topic over secondary education affordability, accessibility and generational differences. In fact, all those topics are integral to fostering the talented labor pool this community needs.

Lifelong education

Much of the solution to work force challenges involves education. Schooling starting in early childhood and continuing past high school is an essential investment in our community's future. Good workers want opportunities to continue their education at the college level and will need flexible schedules as well as online, evening and weekend class availability to fulfill their goals. Young families want excellent K-12 schools for their children. Employers want excellent schools to attract those working families and to ensure that future workers will be well-educated.

"We need everyone to participate," Swanson said. "They need education and skills so they can participate."

Swanson called for regional, not statewide, planning of economic development programs so that communities can determine what would work best for their particular resources and needs. The state's role should be to support and encourage local efforts.

This work force challenge can be met, as Swanson said, "by a concerted, intelligent effort by Billings area leadership." We know what we've got to do; let's get going to invest strategically in people and education.

Copyright © The Billings Gazette, a division of Lee Enterprises.


What do you think?

Tell us what you thought of this story.

5 stars
Current rating: 5 with 2 ratings.



Talk Back!

Billingsgazette.com encourages readers to engage in civil conversation with their neighbors. Comments that are submitted go into a queue to be moderated and may take several hours to be reviewed. By submitting a comment, you are agreeing to the terms & conditions set out in our comment policy.

If you have any problems with the new Talk Back! system, please email us.

Please log in

E-mail address:

Password:


Keep me logged in?


Don't have an account?
Get one here

Forgot your password?
Reset it here

The comments below are from readers of billingsgazette.com and in no way represent the views of The Billings Gazette or Lee Enterprises.




jaymes said 1 day ago
Rating: 2    
All the more reason we don't need to be handing out 10s of millions in corporate welfare to GE and Cabela's.




TAXED4U said 1 day ago
Rating: 3    
The low unemployment rate is great for Billings. Billings is known for low incomes and expensive housing. If no busy bodies screw up the natural effects of supply and demand - Billings salaries will go up due to natural market forces. Minimum wage laws won't make a hill of beans to anyone but a few entry level jobs (which already have to pay more than min. to attract help). But supply and demand will create an across the board adjustment to salaries in Billings. One that is overdue.




theken said 22 hours ago
Rating: 1    
the problem with Montana not being able to find good employees is the amount of wage what is paid. Last year I moved back to Montana and am making half of what I was making out of the state. I cant understand how some people are making it. It is the employers own fault they cant find good employees. May more and they will stat!!




Dig Me Up & Ravage Me said 17 hours ago
Rating: -1    
There's a labor shortage alright - and there will be until a little hedonism is recognized as a far better motivator for hard work than Friday night in some casino with a dunce-date, hoping the place'll get robbed just to spice things up a little. It's not only Billings, it's anywhere in the middle of this country and Canada too. Those with no life outside their jobs are perfectly happy with the status-quo, but if economic growth is all we can mention and happiness in Billings continues to be measured by how many hours one works with nary a thought of getting something out of it, we'd better start importing Mexicans - old ones. On the plus side, our landscaping would improve drastically. But our kids know what's out there, they know they only get one life, and slaving away for some reward in heaven just doesn't cut it.




alex said 16 hours ago
Rating: 1    
If the job market is tight, wages should start going up. I have three kids who live and work in Billings, and they barely eke out a living. Two have professional degrees and one is in the construction business. Their employers seem to do quite well, but the employees don't seem to reap some of the rewards. I still cannot understand how someone would buy expensive toys or go on cruises when the employees that earn them the income to do that cannot afford to purchase a house. So something doesn't figure here; if the workforce is tight and the economy is moving along, why aren't the wage earners doing better?



Click to enlarge


Stories that have received the most comments in the last 24 hours.


Back to Top | Home | News | Sports | Entertainment | Features | Opinion | Public Notices | Classifieds | Privacy | Terms of Use
Lee Enterprises Regional Newspapers | Butte | Helena | Missoula | Rapid City | Bismarck | Casper | The Prairie Star | Billings Business